Past Chiefs
| 1927 | C. Ensley Clayton* | 1969-70 | George D. Patten |
| 1928 | Claude Irons* | 1971 | Harry M. Gibson, Jr.* |
| 1929 | Robert Madge* | 1972-73 | Kingsley Davison, Sr.* |
| 1930 | Charles J. Reiff* | 1974 | Myron Reed |
| 1931 | Millard Bearmore* | 1975-76 | Grant Apgar |
| 1932 | Raymond Wagner* | 1977-78 | Thomas G. Ward* |
| 1933 | James H. Roe* | 1979 | David C. Geiss* |
| 1934 | J.B. Chester* | 1980-81 | Raymond A. Roe |
| 1935 | Ernest D. Clayton* | 1982 | Douglas Howlett |
| 1936 | Elof Johnson* | 1983-84 | Richard Gibson, Jr.* |
| 1937 | Archie T. Burdge* | 1985-86 | Charles Cottrell |
| 1938 | Parent Roe, Sr.* | 1987 | Gary Reed* |
| 1939 | Kenneth Ely* | 1988 | Michael Nagy |
| 1940 | Thomas H. Polhemus* | 1988 | Leroy Malsbury |
| 1941-42 | Oscar Ketcham, Jr. | 1989-90 | Robert F. Nagy* |
| 1943 | Russell Applegate* | 1991 | Harry Carter |
| 1944 | Joseph Mucha* | 1992-93 | Frank Biddle, III |
| 1945 | Herbert Hansen* | 1994-95 | Ronald North |
| 1946-47 | William Barton* | 1996-97 | Thomas P. Ward |
| 1948 | Allen W. Clayton* | 1998-99 | Maris Gabliks |
| 1949-50 | Melvin Roe* | 2000-01 | George F. Gravatt, Jr. |
| 1951 | Cecil B. Gravatt* | 2002-03 | Chris Pujat |
| 1952-53 | Raymond Roe* | 2004-05 | Stephen Biddle |
| 1954-55 | Harry H. Reed, Sr.* | 2006-07 | Thomas Hubert |
| 1956 | Kenneth A. Eckman* | 2008-09 | Wayne Gravatt |
| 1957-58 | Howard P. Story, Jr.* | 2010-11 | Jason Howlett |
| 1959-60 | James S. Reed* | 2012-13 | Brian Prochnow |
| 1961-62 | Richard Gibson, Sr.* | 2014-15 | Robert Tice |
| 1963-64 | Frank Biddle, Jr.* | 2016-17 | Michael Banasz |
| 1965-66 | Stanley Roe* | 2018-19 | Michael Whitehill |
| 1967-68 | George A. Matthews* | 2020-21 | Gregory A. Player |
* Deceased